I very much appreciate the service provided by the library. The children's section is especially helpful. However, I was surprised to see the DVD "Birth of a Nation" in general circulation. Although it's historical significance cannot be denied, having a Ku Klux Klan propaganda film presented as entertainment and its shameful presentation of inaccurate history in general circulation is both disrespectful and a disservice to the public. Please reconsider the appropriate place for such a film.
STAFF REPLY
Public libraries have an obligation to offer materials which represent a variety of viewpoints. It’s our job to include things in our collection that not everyone will be comfortable with!
Birth of a Nation has been controversial almost from the time of its release in 1915. While most viewers today, as well as film historians, agree that the ideas portrayed are reprehensible, the film reflected the beliefs of many people living in that era, including its director, D.W. Griffith, who was a southerner. As such, it provides us with a lens through which to view the racism that is an inescapable part of our country’s history. At the same time, it included unprecedented technical and artistic elements which revolutionized the way films were made. Because of the film’s importance in the history of film (it was deemed “culturally significant” by the Library of Congress in 1992 and selected for preservation in the National Film Registry), we feel that Birth of a Nation deserves a place on our shelves so that viewers who choose to see it can make up their own minds about Griffith’s controversial masterpiece.